Employee shareholding

BSA: How They Work, Beneficiaries and Tax Treatment

BSA (stock warrants): how they work, eligible recipients (employees, directors, contractors), taxation and key use cases.


💡 Warning

This article is the result of automatic translation, the accuracy and fidelity of the translation are therefore not guaranteed. To consult the original version of this article, in French, click here.

 

Attracting and retaining talent is a fundamental step in a company’s development.

To achieve this, there are various equity incentive solutions available: BSPCE, stock options, bonus shares (AGA), and BSA. These employee stock ownership plans help engage company stakeholders more deeply in the company’s growth.

Stock subscription warrants (BSA) offer their holders the opportunity to purchase one or more shares at a set price during a fixed period, thereby increasing their stake in the company or acquiring an equity interest.

What are BSA? Who is eligible for them? What are their benefits? Let’s take a closer look.

💡Key takeaways

  • A BSA is a financial instrument that gives the holder the right — but not the obligation — to purchase shares at a price set in advance, before a specified deadline.

  • BSA are issued by joint-stock companies — SA, SAS, SCA — and the issuance must be authorised by the extraordinary general meeting.

  • Beneficiaries may be employees, corporate officers or third parties — e.g. service providers — unlike BSPCE, which are reserved for employees and corporate officers.

  • Point of attention: if the grant conditions or the price are “preferential”, there may be a risk of reclassification, depending on the facts.

 

 

What is a BSA? 

A stock subscription warrant is a financial instrument as defined inArticle L211-1 of the French Monetary and Financ , and more specifically a security (Article L211-2 of the French Monetary and Financial Code), issued by a corporation.

The legal framework governing the issuance of stock subscription warrants is thus governed by the rules applicable to securities (Article L228-91 et seq. of the Commercial Code).

This warrant grants its holder the right to acquire one or more shares at a specified exercise price and up to a specified expiration date. As such, it is an option on existing or future shares. In fact, the holder of a BSA is under no obligation to purchase these shares. The shares are only allocated to the holder upon subscription and payment of the exercise price.

 

BSA, BSPCE, and Bonus Shares: What Are the Differences? 

BSA, BSPCE, and bonus share allocations (AGA) are all mechanisms designed to give beneficiaries a stake in the company’s share capital. Despite their common purpose, these employee stock ownership mechanisms have major differences.

Introduced by the 2005 Finance Act, the allocation of bonus shares allows the recipient to become a shareholder of the company at no cost. Under a BSA, the holder becomes a shareholder only if they decide to purchase the shares at a preferential price.

As for business founder share subscription warrants (BSPCE), they may only be granted to employees and corporate officers of the company. Recipients of BSA warrants may include both company stakeholders and third parties. 

 

Who can issue BSA warrants? 

The issuance of stock subscription warrants is limited to corporations: SA, SAS, and SCA, whether listed or unlisted. This is indeed statedin Article L228-91, paragraph 1, of the French Commercial Code : joint-stockcompaniesmay issue securities granting access to the capital or entitling the holder to the allocation of debt securities.”

Furthermore, pursuant to Article L228-92, paragraph 1, of the aforementioned Code, the extraordinary general meeting of shareholders has sole authority to authorize the issuance of stock subscription warrants (BSAs).

Who is eligible? 

A distinctive feature of BSA is that they are not exclusively reserved for the company’s employees and executives. Third parties outside the company may also be eligible for these warrants.

BSA warrants may thus be granted, in particular, to:

  • The company’s employees
  • Corporate officers
  • External service providers (consultants, freelancers, etc.)

The exact terms (price, schedule, clauses, and any attendance or performance requirements) must be specified in the plan documentation.

How do stock option warrants work? 

Stock option warrants come with an exercise period during which the beneficiary can acquire the shares at a predetermined price. The exercise of the warrants may also be subject to performance or attendance requirements.

Exercise Period 

BSA holders have a certain period of time (ranging from a few months to several years) to exercise their rights and subscribe for shares. There is no general legal requirement regarding this matter. (Articles L228-91 and L228-92 of the Commercial Code)

In principle, the length of the exercise period is determined based on the company’s objectives: raising funds, rewarding employees, etc. Generally speaking, when the warrants are granted to foster loyalty and motivate beneficiaries, the exercise period spans several years to provide greater flexibility.

 

Exercise Price 

Like the exercise period, the exercise price is determined at the company’s discretion.

When the stock option is intended to reward company stakeholders, the price may be set based on the company’s valuation. The stock option holder will exercise the option only if they believe the company’s valuation has exceeded the exercise price.

In any case, the exercise price must be consistent with the actual value of the issuing company; otherwise, there is a risk of reclassification depending on the circumstances.

 

 

Exercise Conditions

As with BSPCE options, the exercise of BSA warrants may be subject to certain requirements:

  • Presence requirement : This requirement obligates the employee or executive to remain with the company until the date the subscription warrant is exercised. This requirement is part of a strategy to retain employees;
  • Performance condition : These conditions are financial or operational in nature and depend on the duties performed by the warrant holder.

 

What are the benefits of BSA warrants? 

The BSA mechanism offers advantages for both the issuing company and the beneficiary.

For the issuing company 

Stock option warrants allow the company to reward, motivate, and retain employees, executives, and certain partners. The goal is to encourage performance and participation in the company’s growth.  

For beneficiaries 

Stock option warrants allow the holder to become a shareholder of the company without having to immediately make a contribution equivalent to the acquisition cost “at market price.” 

Conclusion

Stock option warrants are a flexible tool for providing access to equity, particularly when the company wishes to include beneficiaries beyond just employees and corporate officers.

To move forward without unnecessary risk, the key is to clearly define the terms (price, timeline, conditions, clauses) and to validate the structure in light of the company’s situation and that of the beneficiaries.

 

Sources 

  1. Monetary and Financial Code, Art. L211-1 — Legifrance —
  2. Monetary and Financial Code, Art. L211-2 — Legifrance —
  3. Commercial Code — Section “Securities Granting Access to Capital” (Art. L228-91 et seq.) — Legifrance —
  4. Commercial Code, Art. L228-91 — Legifrance —
  5. Commercial Code, Art. L228-92 — Legifrance —
  6. Finance Act for 2005 — Legifrance —
  7. General Tax Code, Art. 163 bis G (BSPCE) — Legifrance —
  8. BOI-RSA-ES-20-40 (BSPCE) — BOFiP —
  9. BOI-RSA-ES-20-60 (Management packages) — BOFiP —

Is a Warrant (BSA) a Share?

No. A BSA (Share Subscription Warrant) is a right to purchase shares under predefined terms. Until it is exercised, it does not grant shareholder status.

Am I required to exercise my BSAs?

No. In practice, if exercising the warrant has no economic benefit (or if the applicable conditions are not met), the BSA may simply remain unexercised until it expires.

Can BSAs be granted to freelancers?

Yes. This is often one of the key advantages of BSAs.

What is the tax treatment of BSAs?

It depends heavily on the specific circumstances (e.g., sale of the BSA, exercise followed by sale of the shares, whether the holder is an employee or executive, whether the warrant was granted on preferential terms, the level of investment risk assumed, etc.).

If the BSAs are part of a management package, the applicable tax regime and its conditions are addressed by the French tax authorities. (Source: BOI-RSA-ES-20-60 — BOFiP).

Where a management package is involved, the risk of tax recharacterization and the applicable tax treatment must be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

 

 

Articles associés

Subscribe to our Newsletter to receive the latest news on managing your shareholding